Modifying Permitting Rules. Please Join Me in the Fight

I had made a posting about this just before shut-down. It was obviously a last priority at that point. Recently I sent out the email below to Mayor Garcetti and to all of the Los Angeles councilmen. So far, I have had only one response. However, if you will join me, it might have more weight.

The email I sent:

I do believe that the current regulations of FilmLA are actually losing the city money. The rules were made for much larger productions, with bigger budgets, than are often taking place at this time in history. I have a location. I follow the rules. However, several times a month I have to turn down bookings either because the fee is too high or the waiting time too long. The client simply books with another venue which does not require permits. So in the end, the rules are broken and FilmLA/ the City gets nothing.

FILMING:

Filming always used to mean a substantial production with a lot of people, trucks, equipment, generators, etc. Shooting digitally with LED lighting now allows a smaller footprint, less impact on neighbors, smaller crews. We’ve had documentary interviews with a crew of two and one subject.
There is more “filming” than ever, with smaller budgets. It would help the entire community if the process, requirements, and fees were reviewed and adjusted to reflect today’s production environment.

In 2017 you launched a pilot program, the Digital Makers Initiative, to address this issue. To quote Mayor Garcetti, “Los Angeles has always been home to pioneers of the entertainment industry, and we should take down barriers to the kind of creative, future-minded innovation that small digital filmmakers represent.” I am sorry to see these barriers rebuilt.

Indeed, the films I have been turning down generally have a crew of no more than 25 people, usually under 15. There are no explosions, no stunts, no car chases, or anything which would be dangerous or impact the neighbors as long as the parking rules are maintained.

STILL PHOTOGRAPHY:

Here, the fees for the permit alone are fair. However, since the shoots are usually set up last minute (as are most of the film shoots) the waiting time is prohibitive. Most of these shoots are either fashion shoots or celebrity shoots with 3 to 12 people. They generally last only 4 to 6 hours, sometimes less. The impact on the neighborhood is less than that of a dinner party. I would like to suggest that on these tiny shoots you lessen the waiting time and eliminate the need for notification. In the digital age, checking for the insurance & parking should be able to be done instantly online in the same way as we can get approval for credit cards instantly.

To sum up my suggestions for modification:
• • Reduce the fees for smaller films with generally the same rules as the defunct Digital Makers Initiative
• • Reduce the waiting time for small films either by putting someone on to oversee it during the weekends and on holidays
• • Give instant approval for small still shoots according to an algorithm.
• • Eliminate the need for neighbor notification on small still shoots. This will also enable low-budget shoots to pay the fees and to generally follow the rules.
Thank for taking the time to read and consider this,

4 Likes

Hi Yvonne,
I completely agree with your letter. Please lmk if you received a reply. I will send an email as well. LMK if you have any new info.

2 Likes

I only got a reply from councilman Ryu. He said he would take it into consideration. It was a rather generic letter. However, I believe that if more people wrote to the mayor and to all of the councilmen, it would be taken more seriously. That is why I posted it here. You can easily find a list of the councilmen and the mayor here:

I wrote not only to my representative, but to all in Los Angeles since I believe this is a city-wide issue. So if you and anyone else you know could join me, perhaps we could see some change.

Yvonne

2 Likes

Hello Yvonne, your letter is very well thought out, and very well written, and I believe you are addressing an important issue. I assume you live in LA county, the funny thing is filming rules are much more stringent here than almost any other city in the US.
I personally know of a couple of attempts to address this through other platforms, however I don’t think this will change. One of my pet peeves, which is one you describe, is that some hosts are not aware of filming rules, or don’t feel obliged to enforce them, and therefore give clients the impression that it’s us who are being difficult. I feel, in Los Angeles County, the platform should also make it mandatory to get permits, just as location companies do. This would make Peerspace much more respected by the city, and would level the playing field for the hosts. I personally really agree with you, that especially in the time of Covid, some of these shoots are so small, and many do not have real commercial interests, making it unfair for some people. With that being said, many larger companies, with plenty of money, and big commercial interests, are shooting smaller productions, as they are adapting to a new norm, and they also don’t want to get permits. Which leaves us hosts having to defend the permit system. In my case, I always insist on a permit, and I have to explain why to a lot of people. Peerspace should make permitting mandatory in Los Angeles at least, but also try and negotiate with the city, a simpler permit system for smaller groups, (perhaps under 10). This obviously won’t be popular with many hosts, but it’s they only legal and fair way to give equality to the platform, and set an example that is compliant with the city.

1 Like

Thank you for your Permit fight and letter. Is there anybody else in the LA or Santa Clarita area having a Permit issue??
We have a “lovely” neighbor on the tippy corner of our property near the entrance in the cul-de-sac that counts cars going past his house. And then try’s to video tape them in our back yard. Now, he can’t really see them very well or hear us in the 6.5 acres in the back but he will still call the sheriff to say we are filming. Like you, we are catering to small groups People rent 1-5 hrs or sometimes a day but mostly 5-15 people some bigger. but we can fit 50 cars on the land.
I was even told if I want to photograph in my back yard (because of him calling) I would need to get a permit unless I was photographing my family or a wedding. I agree with you letter I am in the city of Santa Clarita and its 808.00 with fees to film even one hour. we have been flagged as a problem property. I did tell him it has back fired on him and we will be only looking for bigger productions that can pay the large permit fees because of him.